Skip to content

Highland Global Business Valuations

Experience Matters Most

  • SBA Business Valuations: Trust the Experts
    • About Us
    • Our Services
      • Business Valuations
      • Strategic Advisory
      • Appraisal Review
      • ESOP Valuations
    • Our Philosophy
  • Message from Our Founder
  • How To Value A Business
  • Unlocking SBA 7(a) Loans: Business Valuation Explained
    • SBA 7(a) Official Resources & Lending Data
    • SBA 7(a) Valuation Video Library
    • Lender Resources & Checklists
    • SBA 7a Business Valuation Myths
  • Valuation Insights & Articles
    • Publications
      • 10 Reasons Business Owners Need a Business Appraiser
      • Top 10 Questions Of Value
      • Family Limited Partnership
      • State Of The Economy
    • 7a Business Valuation Field Notes
    • Case Studies
    • In The News
  • 7 Deadly Sins Book Series
    • The 7 Deadly Sins Articles
  • Experience Matters Most: Where Judgement Meets Reality
    • Leadership
    • Due Diligence
    • Risk Mitigation
    • Integration
    • Professionalism & Humility
    • Relationships
    • Relationship vs Reputation Repair
    • Goodwill & Value Erosion
    • Deal Attachment
    • The Discipline of Professional Composure
    • The Quiet Truths
    • The Performance of Expertise
    • Boundaries of Professional Engagement
    • Explanations Are Not Evidence
    • Professional Courtesy Is Not a Soft Skill
    • Charlotte: The Unexpected Source of Leadership Lessons
  • Community & Associations
  • The Robert M. Clinger III Invitational Golf Tournament
  • Contact Us

A Valuation Is Not a Box to Check

March 28, 2026April 10, 2026 ~ Certified Business Appraiser

One of the more dangerous attitudes in lending and transaction work is the quiet belief that valuation is just a box to check.

It is not.

The moment someone says, in effect, “We just need to get through the requirement,” the process is already at risk of being misunderstood.

A valuation is not there to decorate a credit file. It is not there to provide procedural cover. It is not there to make an uncomfortable transaction appear orderly simply because a report exists somewhere in the package.

A valuation requirement exists because value matters. And when the likely conclusion is materially below the purchase price, that is not a technical nuisance. That is not an administrative inconvenience. That is the very point of the exercise.

I have seen situations where a lender contact treats the valuation as secondary because “there is plenty of other collateral.” That kind of thinking confuses two entirely different concepts.

Collateral may matter to loan structure. Collateral may matter to credit protection. Collateral does not transform an unsupported business value into a supportable one.

Those are not interchangeable ideas.

If the value is required, then the value matters. And if the value does not support the transaction, no one should pretend the assignment was merely ceremonial from the beginning.

A process that is treated like a box-checking exercise rarely produces respect for the answer when the answer becomes inconvenient. That is why professionals have to be willing to say what others may not want to hear: If you only want the requirement satisfied, you may not actually want an independent valuation. You may simply want the appearance of one.

Share this:

  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Print (Opens in new window) Print
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
Like Loading...

Related

Posted in Boundaries of Professional Engagement

Post navigation

< Previous Some of the Most Important Valuation Work Happens Before the Engagement Letter Is Signed
Next > Collateral Does Not Cure an Unsupported Value Conclusion
  • LinkedIn

Top Posts

  • BIZCOMPS, ValuSource Market Comps, and DealStats in Business Valuation
  • The Rainbow Bridge
  • Business Valuation Under USPAP: A Guide for Credible and Defensible Appraisals
  • Understanding Capital Structure’s Impact on Business Valuation: A Guide for Bankers
  • Estimating the Cost of Equity Capital for Private Company Valuation
  • Distributions and the S Corporation: Understanding Their Role in Financial Statements
  • 🧠 WACC ≠ Cost of Equity
  • The 10th Annual Robert M. Clinger III Invitational Golf Tournament at The Dunes Golf & Beach Club
Website Powered by WordPress.com.
  • Reblog
  • Subscribe Subscribed
    • Highland Global Business Valuations
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Highland Global Business Valuations
    • Subscribe Subscribed
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
%d